« An Inkjet Print, As Seen Through a Scanning Electron Microscope | Main | A Note to Paper Manufacturers »
Thursday
May122011

Dwell/Blurb’s Photo Competition Fine Print

Well, it’s not quite a scam, but wow. I recently came across the Dwell/Blurb contest called World Views. They invite submissions through May 15th that show different takes on the modern world. An “esteemed panel of judges” will select the winners.

If you win, what do you get? Not much. A $250 gift certificate to Blurb, a year’s subscription to Dwell (worth $9.37 given current subscription prices at online magazine outlets), tickets to 2011 Dwell on Design (worth around $45), and “winning recognition and photo credit” in the book (which presumably, if you win, you’ll order copies of using your gift certificate).

Yeah, so the prize is kinda lame. But why am I so bothered by the competition? It’s because of the fine print. If you read the Rules & Regulations there’s the following gem:

8. Sponsors’ Ownership of Submissions: Each Submission becomes the exclusive property of Sponsors, and the contents, images, concepts and ideas embodied therein may be used by Sponsors for commercial, marketing and other promotional purposes. By entering a Submission, each entrant hereby irrevocably assigns to Sponsors all right, title and interest in and to the Submission and its contents, and agrees that Sponsors may use, reproduce, display, and distribute such Submission and its contents, without any compensation to or acknowledgment of the entrant (other than the prize, as set forth in these Official Rules). By entering a Submission, each entrant consents to the potential use of their entry in a photograph book to be co-produced and sold by Sponsors. Each entrant agrees that they will not receive any compensation even if Sponsors profit from the sales of the photography book.

In a nutshell: if you enter, they own your image. Period. They can do anything they want with it, forever. It’s not even that you’re giving them a non-exclusive license, you’re saying the image becomes their exclusive property.

Geez.

Reader Comments (2)

Blurb is also running a Photography Book Now competition with a $25,000 first prize. Below is part of their 'fine print', which looks similar to what you wrote about.

"Sponsor reserves the right, but not the obligation, to display and distribute the Submissions for promotional purposes. By entering this Promotion, you grant the Sponsor a royalty-free, world-wide, fully paid-up, perpetual, irrevocable, non-exclusive right and license to use, reproduce, distribute, modify, adapt, and publicly display your submission; and to make derivative works of the Submissions, or edit Submission for practical and cost considerations, for use as display models in trade shows and exhibitions, and for promotional purposes."

So I wrote them asking what it meant in layman's terms and this was their response:

"By entering Photography Book Now, you are giving permission for the competition sponsors to use the book for promotional purposes. You will not be granting Blurb or other sponsors ownership of your content."

Somehow I get the feeling there is something not quite right here. They are saying that I won't be granting them ownership of my content, just the right to change it as they see fit.

Hmmmm...

May 12, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterhokuahi

At least in the Blurb Photography Book Now competition (which they run every year) you are only granting them royalty-free, non-exclusive rights to use your content. You aren't granting them complete ownership of it like the Dwell/Blurb joint contest.

But as you note, they get to do whatever they want with your photo and can make derivitive works of it.

Neil

May 12, 2011 | Registered CommenterNeil Enns

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
Some HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <code> <em> <i> <strike> <strong>